Skip to content
Recover Ortho Clinic logoDr. Himanshu SinghLimb ReconstructionOrtho · Shoulder · Knee

Shoulder

Rotator Cuff Tear: Night Pain, Weakness & Treatment Options

Shoulder pain at night and difficulty lifting the arm are classic signs of a rotator cuff problem. Learn which tears heal with physiotherapy and when arthroscopic repair is the better choice.

Dr. Himanshu Singh, orthopaedic surgeonBy Dr. Himanshu Singh, MBBS, D'Ortho, DNB (Orthopaedics)12 October 20263 min read

The rotator cuff is a group of four tendons that wrap around the ball of the shoulder. They keep the ball centred in the socket and lift and rotate the arm. Tears are very common, especially after 40 — sometimes after a fall or lifting injury, often gradually with age-related wear.

Symptoms

  • Pain on the outer side of the upper arm, worse at night and lying on the affected side
  • Pain or weakness lifting the arm overhead or reaching behind
  • Difficulty combing hair, dressing or reaching a shelf
  • Clicking or catching
  • Sudden loss of lift after an injury — suggests an acute tear needing early assessment

Types of tears

  • Partial-thickness: the tendon is frayed but not torn through
  • Full-thickness: a hole through the tendon, from small to massive
  • Traumatic: sudden tear in a previously healthy tendon — better results with early repair
  • Degenerative: develops over years, often with bone spurs and impingement

Diagnosis

Examination tests specific strength and movement of each cuff tendon. X-rays show bone spurs, arthritis and the position of the ball. MRI is the key scan — it shows tear size, retraction and muscle quality (fatty change), which predict whether repair will heal. Ultrasound is a useful alternative in some cases.

Illustration, MRI and arthroscopy of a full-thickness rotator cuff tear
Full-thickness supraspinatus tear: (a) illustration, (b) MRI showing the tear through the tendon (arrows), and (c) the same tear seen at arthroscopy.Image: Yubran et al., Insights Imaging 2024 · CC BY 4.0

Treatment options

Non-surgical

  • Physiotherapy focused on the cuff and shoulder-blade muscles
  • Activity modification and pain relief
  • Image-guided injections for pain relief to allow rehabilitation

Many partial and degenerative tears do well with this approach.

Arthroscopic rotator cuff repair

Through small keyhole incisions, the torn tendon is reattached to bone with suture anchors, in a single- or double-row configuration. Bone spurs can be removed at the same time. Repair is recommended for:

  • Acute traumatic tears in active patients
  • Tears causing persisting pain and weakness despite physiotherapy
  • Tears in younger patients, before the tendon retracts and the muscle weakens

Massive or irreparable tears

Partial repair, superior capsular reconstruction, tendon transfer, or reverse shoulder replacement for older patients with arthritis and loss of elevation.

Recovery after repair

Typical timeline in my practice; your plan may differ.

  • Sling for about 4–6 weeks while the tendon heals to bone
  • Assisted movement first, then active movement from about 6 weeks
  • Strengthening from about 3 months
  • Most daily activities by 3–4 months; full strength 6–12 months

See the shoulder recovery guide.

Don't ignore persistent shoulder pain

Not all shoulder pain is a cuff tear — frozen shoulder, arthritis and labral tears can feel similar. A precise diagnosis is the first step to the right treatment.

Frequently asked questions

Can a rotator cuff tear heal without surgery?

Partial tears and many degenerative tears in older adults improve with physiotherapy, as surrounding muscles compensate. Full-thickness tears do not heal back to bone on their own and may enlarge over time, particularly after an injury in an active person.

Is an MRI needed for rotator cuff tears?

MRI is the most useful scan for rotator cuff tears. It shows the size of the tear, how far the tendon has retracted, and whether the muscle has become fatty — all of which decide whether repair is likely to succeed.

What if the tear is too large to repair?

Options for massive irreparable tears include partial repair, tendon transfers, superior capsular reconstruction, and reverse shoulder replacement in older patients with arthritis or loss of arm elevation.

Medical disclaimer: this article is general information, not a diagnosis. Every injury is different — please consult an orthopaedic surgeon with your scans before deciding on treatment.

Not sure what your scans mean? Get a clear plan.

Bring your X-rays, MRI or CT and previous reports. You'll leave knowing your diagnosis, every reasonable option — including non-surgical ones — and what recovery really involves.