Skip to content
Recover Ortho Clinic logoDr. Himanshu SinghLimb ReconstructionOrtho · Shoulder · Knee

Limb Reconstruction

Non-union: When a Fracture Doesn't Heal — Causes & Treatment

Still in pain or feeling movement at a fracture months after injury? Learn why bones fail to unite, how non-union is confirmed, and how Ilizarov and modern fixation restore healing.

Dr. Himanshu Singh, orthopaedic surgeonBy Dr. Himanshu Singh, MBBS, D'Ortho, DNB (Orthopaedics)30 October 20264 min read

A broken bone normally heals in 6–12 weeks in the upper limb and 3–6 months in the leg. When healing stops altogether, the fracture is called a non-union. Patients usually describe persistent pain, swelling, a feeling of movement at the break, a bent or broken implant, or simply being unable to bear weight months after the injury.

Non-union is one of the commonest reasons patients are referred for limb reconstruction — and with the right plan, the large majority can be healed.

Why do fractures fail to unite?

Bone healing needs three things: stability, blood supply (biology) and the absence of infection. A non-union almost always means one or more of these is missing.

  • Mechanical causes: fixation that is too flexible or too rigid, an implant that has broken or loosened, or a gap left between fragments.
  • Biological causes: high-energy injuries that stripped the bone of its blood supply, open fractures, extensive surgical dissection.
  • Infection: low-grade infection can silently prevent healing — see our guide on infected non-union.
  • Patient factors: smoking, diabetes, vitamin D deficiency, poor nutrition, some medicines (steroids, certain painkillers).

Types of non-union

Type What X-rays show What it usually needs
Hypertrophic Plenty of callus ("elephant foot") but no bridging More stability — biology is good
Oligotrophic Little callus, reasonable alignment Stability plus stimulation
Atrophic Thin, rounded bone ends, no callus Biology — bone graft, freshening of ends
Infected Sequestrum, sinus, loose implant Debridement and staged reconstruction

How is non-union diagnosed?

  1. Clinical examination — pain or movement at the fracture site, alignment, leg length, skin condition.
  2. X-rays in two planes, and full-length standing X-rays if the leg is short or crooked.
  3. CT scan — the most reliable way to confirm whether bone is bridging.
  4. Blood tests — ESR, CRP, counts, vitamin D, sugar, and thyroid where relevant.
  5. Cultures taken at surgery if infection is suspected.
X-ray of tibial non-union with broken plate
X-rays of a shin bone (tibia) fracture that has failed to unite: the fracture line is still visible and the plate has broken (arrows) — a typical sign of non-union.Image: Wang et al., Front Surg 2026 · CC BY 4.0

Treatment options

Revision fixation and bone grafting

For many hypertrophic and some atrophic non-unions, removing the failed implant, stabilising with a stronger plate or nail, and adding the patient's own bone graft (usually from the pelvis) is enough.

Exchange nailing

In long bones like the femur and tibia, reaming and inserting a larger nail improves stability and stimulates healing.

Ilizarov ring fixator

The Ilizarov method treats non-union, shortening, deformity and infection in a single plan. Thin wires and rings hold the bone securely while allowing early weight bearing, which itself stimulates healing. The frame can compress the non-union, correct angulation and — if needed — lengthen the bone or transport a segment to fill a gap.

Correcting the underlying cause

Stopping smoking, correcting vitamin D and controlling blood sugar can make the difference between success and failure.

Key point: the operation that healed the first fracture is rarely the right answer for a non-union. Treatment must address the specific reason the bone stopped healing.

See a real case

Shared with written patient consent, identifying details removed. Individual outcomes vary.

What recovery looks like

Typical timeline in my practice; your plan may differ.

Most patients walk with support soon after surgery. Healing is tracked with X-rays every 4–6 weeks. With plating or nailing, union typically takes 3–6 months; with an Ilizarov frame, the frame stays until X-rays and CT confirm solid bone.

When should you seek an opinion?

  • Pain at a fracture site 3 months after injury
  • A bent, broken or loose implant on X-ray
  • A wound that keeps discharging over a fracture
  • A limb that has become shorter or crooked

Bring every X-ray since the injury, operation notes and implant details to your consultation — the sequence of X-rays often tells the story of why the bone did not heal.

Frequently asked questions

How long before a fracture is called a non-union?

A fracture is usually called a non-union when it has not healed by 6–9 months and X-rays show no progress over the last three months. A delayed union is one that is healing slower than expected but still progressing.

Can a non-union heal without surgery?

Occasionally, a stable non-union with a correctable cause (such as smoking or vitamin D deficiency) may heal with bracing and weight bearing. Most established non-unions need surgery to correct the biological or mechanical problem.

Is the Ilizarov method used for every non-union?

No. Many non-unions heal with revision plating or nailing and bone grafting. The Ilizarov frame is preferred when there is infection, bone loss, shortening, deformity or poor soft tissue.

Medical disclaimer: this article is general information, not a diagnosis. Every injury is different — please consult an orthopaedic surgeon with your scans before deciding on treatment.

Not sure what your scans mean? Get a clear plan.

Bring your X-rays, MRI or CT and previous reports. You'll leave knowing your diagnosis, every reasonable option — including non-surgical ones — and what recovery really involves.