Articular cartilage is the smooth, glistening layer that lets the knee glide. A focal cartilage defect is a patch where that layer is worn, split or knocked off. It is caused by a twisting injury, a kneecap dislocation, an old ligament or meniscus injury, a condition called osteochondritis dissecans, or simply years of overload in a bow-legged or knock-kneed knee.
Because cartilage has no blood supply, a full-thickness defect does not heal by itself, and a defect left in an overloaded knee can progress to arthritis.
Symptoms
- Aching pain with activity, often in one area of the knee
- Swelling after exercise
- Catching, clicking or locking, especially when a loose fragment is present
- Pain on stairs, squatting or kneeling with kneecap defects
Diagnosis
- MRI: shows the size, depth and location of the defect, the bone underneath, and the meniscus and ligaments
- Full-length standing X-ray: checks leg alignment. A defect on the overloaded side of a bow-legged or knock-kneed knee needs alignment correction too
- Arthroscopy: confirms the exact size and grade at the time of treatment
The three treatment approaches
Treatment options fall into three groups:
- Palliation: smoothing loose flaps (chondroplasty, debridement) to relieve mechanical symptoms
- Repair: microfracture or drilling, to bring marrow cells into the defect so that repair tissue forms
- Restoration: replacing the defect with cartilage. This includes autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI/MACI), where your own cartilage cells are grown in a lab and implanted, osteochondral autograft transfer (OAT/mosaicplasty), where plugs of cartilage and bone are moved from a less-used part of the knee, and osteochondral allograft (OCA)
Choosing the right option
| Defect | Typical options |
|---|---|
| Small (under about 2–2.5 cm²), low demand | Debridement and rehabilitation |
| Small, high demand | Microfracture, OAT, ACI/MACI |
| Medium (about 2.5–8 cm²) | ACI/MACI, OAT, osteochondral allograft |
| Large (over 8 cm²) or major bone loss | Osteochondral allograft; knee replacement in older patients |
| Damaged bone under the cartilage | Bone grafting plus ACI/MACI or OAT |
A 2023 review concluded that no single technique suits every defect. The choice depends on the size and location of the lesion, whether bone is involved, and the patient's goals.
Fix the cause, not just the hole
Cartilage repairs fail when the knee keeps overloading them. The most important associated procedures are:
- Alignment correction: HTO for bow legs or DFO for knock-knees, to shift weight off the repaired area
- Meniscus repair or root repair: a missing or torn meniscus overloads the cartilage (see meniscus root tears)
- Ligament reconstruction: an unstable knee damages cartilage with every giving-way episode
- Kneecap stabilisation: for defects caused by kneecap dislocation
Recovery
Typical timeline in my practice; your plan may differ.
| Time | Microfracture | Cartilage transplant (ACI/MACI/OAT) |
|---|---|---|
| 0–6 weeks | Protected weight-bearing; continuous gentle movement | Protected weight-bearing; brace for kneecap defects |
| 6–12 weeks | Full weight-bearing, strengthening | Gradual full weight-bearing |
| 3–6 months | Cycling, swimming, light jogging later | Strengthening; jogging from about 6 months |
| 9–12 months | Return to sport | Return to sport, often 12 months |
The repair tissue matures over many months, so following the rehabilitation plan matters as much as the operation itself.
Frequently asked questions
Can damaged knee cartilage heal on its own?
Very little. Cartilage has no blood supply, so a full-thickness defect does not regrow normal cartilage on its own. Small, low-symptom defects can be managed with strengthening and activity changes, but larger or painful defects in active people often need a repair or restoration procedure.
What is the difference between microfracture and cartilage transplant?
Microfracture makes tiny holes in the bone under the defect so that marrow cells form repair tissue (fibrocartilage). It is a single keyhole procedure suited to small defects. Cartilage transplant techniques such as ACI or MACI grow the patient's own cartilage cells and implant them, or move plugs of cartilage and bone (OATS), and are used for larger defects or when microfracture has failed.
Why does leg alignment matter for cartilage repair?
A cartilage repair in a knee that is bow-legged or knock-kneed sits in the overloaded compartment and is likely to wear out. Correcting alignment with an osteotomy at the same time, or before, moves weight off the repair and is one of the most important factors for a lasting result.
Medical disclaimer: this article is general information, not a diagnosis. Every injury is different — please consult an orthopaedic surgeon with your scans before deciding on treatment.


